Operations

·

5 min read

The sale your POS never sees: what out-of-stocks really cost

An empty shelf doesn't show up as a loss in your sales report. It shows up as nothing at all. Here's how big that "nothing" is, and how to catch it before the holiday weekends.

Avia Research · Retailogists

When a product sells out, your POS records exactly what it should: zero sales. To the report, a sold-out bestseller looks the same as a product nobody wanted. That’s what makes out-of-stocks so expensive. The loss is real, but it’s invisible.

A $1.73 trillion problem

The IHL Group’s 2025 inventory distortion study puts the global cost of out-of-stocks and overstocks at $1.73 trillion a year, or 6.5% of global retail sales. North American retailers alone lose about $415 billion.

Two causes stand out in IHL’s breakdown: supply chain disruption ($301 billion) and personnel issues ($248 billion), meaning shelves that don’t get refilled because no one has time during the rush.

The retailers getting it right are pulling ahead. IHL found that retailers using AI and machine learning for inventory achieved 2.3x higher sales growth and 2.5x higher profit growth than those relying on traditional methods.

Shoppers don't wait

An out-of-stock isn't just one lost sale. It often sends the customer to a competitor. In its 2024 holiday consumer survey, AlixPartners found that 66% of consumers will shop elsewhere if an item is out of stock. When an item wasn't available in store:

  • 36% ordered it online from the same retailer

  • 34% ordered it from a different retailer

  • 31% went to another physical store

The same study found that in-store assortments average just 9% of the size of the same retailer's online range. With fewer products on the floor, every missing bestseller hurts more.

Why the POS can’t warn you

Sales data can tell you a product stopped selling. It can’t tell you why. Was demand down, or was the shelf empty? Without context, the usual reaction is to order less, which makes the next stockout more likely.

Traffic data adds the missing context. If visitors are steady or rising while sales of a usually reliable product suddenly drop, the most likely explanation is that shoppers came looking for it and left without it. Combine that with sales velocity and you can spot a stockout while it’s happening, not after the weekend is over.

A pre-holiday stockout checklist

  1. List your top 20 sellers per store. These drive a large share of revenue and cause the most damage when they run out.

  2. Forecast demand from traffic, not last week's sales. Sales during a stockout understate real demand. Traffic forecasts don't.

  3. Restock before the peak, not during it. Schedule replenishment for Thursday and Friday ahead of big weekends, when staff have time.

  4. Set alerts on velocity drops. Flag any top seller whose sales fall sharply while store traffic holds steady.

  5. Review lost-opportunity hours every Monday. Look at the hours where traffic was high and conversion fell. Check what was out of stock at the time.

Every stockout you catch before a busy weekend is revenue that would otherwise have walked out the door and never shown up in a report. This holiday season, more shoppers will arrive knowing exactly what they want. Make sure it's on the shelf when they get there.

Sources

Stay updated

Montréal, CAN

E-commerce analytics for physical retail.

Connect Shopify POS with in-store traffic insights.

© 2026 Retailogists Inc.

Stay updated

Montréal, CAN

E-commerce analytics for physical retail.

Connect Shopify POS with in-store traffic insights.

© 2026 Retailogists Inc.

Stay updated

Montréal, CAN

E-commerce analytics for physical retail.

Connect Shopify POS with in-store traffic insights.

© 2026 Retailogists Inc.

Stay updated

Montréal, CAN

E-commerce analytics for physical retail.

Connect Shopify POS with in-store traffic insights.

© 2026 Retailogists Inc.